My friend Cathy has a new hobby. She likes to build motorcycles. Right now her pride and joy is a 30-year old moped that’s parked on the porch of her house. When she showed me that ancient hunk of metal, I was partly reminded of Pee-Wee Herman from Pee-Wee’s Big Adventure and partly reminded of Mr. McFeely from Mr. Rogers’ Neighborhood. I don’t know why. Cathy is determined to start a motorcycle gang/club to terrorize the streets of the San Fernando Valley, and she’s been persistent on getting me interested in motorcycles and joining her terror cell. So far she has no members. While the thought of cruising Van Nuys Boulevard and picking up chicks on a Harley is mightily intriguing, the thought of cracking my skull and having my brain splattered all over Sherman Way does not interest me at all. (I am highly inept at driving a manual transmission automobile. What makes me think I can shift gears on a fucking chopper?) However, my existence is inconsequential. I told Cathy that I’d “think about it.”
I don’t know if anyone has noticed, but America has been obsessed with motorcycles over the past few years. This is evident by the plethora of motorcycle television shows (like the one with the man who is married to Sandra Bullock) on cable channels that no one watches (like Discovery and TLC, I think). Leather jacket sales have increased 1000 fold (approximately) over the past 5 years. Happy Days ratings on Nick-at-Nite have skyrocketed (probably not true). I have no explanation for the motorcycle renaissance. I suppose I could make a weak and unoriginal commentary about how a motorcycle is a metaphorical extension of a man’s genitals and how that is a reflection of our sex-crazed American society, but, much like my life, that commentary would be boring and dispirited. I don’t need to be reminded of such things.
I suppose American trends come and go (along with motorcycles, America presently also has a fascination with penguins). One of the biggest trends in recent memory was reality television. Some reality shows did really well and are still around (Survivor, Dancing With The Stars), while others blew really hard (Being Bobby Brown, Flavor of Love). (Oddly enough, Temptation Island did not blow at all but didn’t do well, either.) But the show that could best epitomize the reality TV craze is American Idol. But unlike other reality shows, it’s not part of the trend.
American Idol captured American audiences and changed television programming forever. Thirty million people watch this show every week. Why do so many people watch American Idol? I doubt it’s because of the singing, but I have a theory: It filled the void for non-sports fans to become sports fans. Ever since its debut in 2002, American Idol has become the 5th largest sport in North America, behind football, baseball, basketball, and hockey. It became America’s first exclusively primetime sport. A season of American Idol begins in January and continues until its championship game in late May. Millions of people watch this show and support, cheer, and vote for their favorite contestant. Most of the time a person’s favorite contestant has nothing to do with the contestant’s singing ability, just like a person’s favorite sports team most of the time has nothing to do with the team’s ability to play the particular sport. In sports, a person usually chooses a team as their “favorite” for some arbitrary reason that has nothing to do with the sport. For example, I became a fan of the Miami Dolphins when I was a kid because I used to like dolphins. For reasons I will never understand, I am still a fan today. I’ve been a fan through the good seasons and the bad seasons, and all because I used to like dolphins back when I didn’t know any better. Most of my friends are Los Angeles Lakers fans for no reason other than that they are from Los Angeles. Most Lakers fans know nothing about basketball, but they attend Lakers games because Staples Center is a great spot for hipsters and yuppies. Fans are loyal to their teams for arbitrary reasons, so the truth is that the concept of fandom is lame, in general. Sports fandom makes no sense whatsoever. Sports fans aren’t very bright.
The same is true for American Idol. The spirit of the show is about letting non-sports fans behave like sports fans. The singular aspect that makes the show great is that it releases peoples’ inhibitions about being completely nonsensical. People like whoever is the prettiest (Carrie Underwood), or the gayest (Clay Aiken) or the goofiest (Taylor Hicks). People cheer for whoever is from their home state (Jasmine Trias), or whoever is the most Indian (Sanjaya Malakar), or whoever could eat the most ham hocks (Ruben Studdard). Similar to how sports fandom is never about sports, American Idol is never about the singing. The show LETS US PICK our favorite! They never said we had to vote for the best singer, and there is absolutely nothing wrong with that. If it was about the singing and the talent, then Simon, Kara, and Randy would just tell us who the best singer is. And if you’re the type who gets upset when the “best singer” gets voted off and the “worst singer” gets to stick around, then you’re just a loser, or a “poor sport”. If you’re really into singing and talent, then go to your local record store and pick up a CD because there’s tons of great music over there and you can listen to it all you want.
American Idol isn’t a trend. And it’s not even a talent competition. It’s a sport. And, like it or not, it’s here to stay. This is the beginning of March Madness. So fill out your brackets and pick Didi Benami over Crystal Bowersox for the win.